Tuesday, March 24, 2026

Feedback Request

The author of the book featured in Face-Lift 1559 would like feedback on the following version of the query.


 Dear XXX

I am seeking representation for The Black Bear Inn, an 85,000-word mystery set on Minnesota’s rugged North Shore. For readers who enjoy Listen for the Lie by Amy Tintera and None of This is True by Lisa Jewell, this novel combines atmospheric small-town suspicion, a framed protagonist, and a media-driven investigation.


Out of options, self-proclaimed city girl Adeline Sinclair reluctantly returns to her family cabin on Lake Superior, accepting a job at the Black Bear Inn. For the first time in her life, she’s accepted into a friend group thanks to her charming manager, Val Grant, but her fresh start is threatened when a stack of photos and [No need to mention photos if you don't say what they depict.] a note addressed to Val arrives at the Inn: Stay out of it. [Maybe that message should be in all caps.] Val is cagey when pressed for answers, and days later, Val goes missing. Adeline turns to Val’s boyfriend for comfort, unable to deny her feelings for him. [It seems to me Val's boyfriend is more likely to need comforting than Val's employee.] When Val’s body washes up on shore with suspicious injuries, and a photo of Adeline kissing Val’s boyfriend surfaces online, the community accuses Adeline of Val’s murder. 


Once again, Adeline’s left alone, grappling with guilt. Desperate to clear her name, she [joins forces with Jackson Thorne,} follows the clues Val unknowingly left behind, confronting Jackson Thorne, a guest at the Inn: a true crime podcaster [who'd been] working with Val to uncover crimes against women on the North Shore. Adeline joins forces with Jackson, and together they discover another woman has vanished, just as the police are closing in on Adeline. Now a formal suspect, she [Adeline realizes she’s being framed by the one person who’s claimed to believe her. But can she prove it] must uncover what Val was about to expose before the police arrest her--and before the killer can silence her?—a killer would do anything to silence the missing woman who turns up dead—before she’s arrested for a crime she didn’t commit. Adeline discovers she’s being framed by the one person who’s claimed to believe her, but who will believe an outsider? 


(Bio)


Thank you for your time and consideration! I would be delighted to provide you with the full manuscript upon request. 


Notes


It's better now, with more specific information. 


I'm not convinced Adeline would be unable to deny her feelings for Val's boyfriend at this point. It undoubtedly makes sense in the book, but as this is a mystery, it might be better to leave the romantic angle out of the query.]

3 comments:

  1. Thank you! I wasn't sure how to incorporate the affair. Since the photo of them kissing is what prompts Adeline to be a suspect, it seemed I needed to provide backstory?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Boyfriend/girlfriend beak-ups usually happen without anyone getting murdered, so it seems like whoever is framing Adeline would come up with something better than this photo. Like planting the murder weapon in Adeline's car. In any case, the photo can still turn up online even if you don't mention that Adeline has feelings for the boyfriend. Was the photo photoshopped, or is it real? If it's real, it makes the boyfriend at least equally suspect. (Though in that case, Val murdering her boyfriend seems more likely than Addie or the boyfriend murdering Val.

    And isn't the main suspect the person who's been committing crimes against women? Don't the police know about that?

    ReplyDelete
  3. The photo (which is real) was posted online by someone else (not the killer). The killer noticed the town was ganging up on Adeline and posting rumors that either she or the boyfriend may have killed Val (because of the affair), and so the killer then started planting other evidence and framing Adeline after the photo was posted.

    The crimes against women are not all connected-the podcast highlights the shitty police work in the area including people in the police department covering things up.

    ReplyDelete